rwarford’s twenty-seven comments

Difficult to classify as Phrygian as there is not a single G in the melody. probably a little more of an Aeolian feel. more…

Another smaller group now, De Temps Antains - all ex La Bottine and of course Les Poules a Colin, a mainly girl band, daughters of members and named after a song which has been a mainstay of La Bottines stage shows. more…

La Bottine Souriante play a version after Brandy Payette on the album ‘Jusqu’aux p‘tites heures’ - brilliant! more…

Seems to be the 4 days of Chrstmas - according to the concertina.net converter. more…

I am guessing that there should be more notes at the end, it would sound very strange ending on that g - needs to arrive on a d more…

Does it sound pentatonic - no it sounds like A major. more…

Clearly A major, it has a limited range but is not really pentatonic, simply never reaches the 6th and 7th degrees. more…

Bees Wax, Sheep Skin is on this site somewhere and the reel at the end of Chistophe is Monymusk. more…

I did not say D dorian. more…

I see no problem with calling this A minor. It cannot be Dorian with all those g#s. more…