"King of the Button Box: Jimmy Shand"
SDP03 (two CDs) ~ http://www.beltonaproject.co.uk/
From the notes ~
We frequently hear from Scots music lovers that they find it increasingly difficult to locate quality CDs of recordings made by the great Scottish accordionist, Jimmy Shand. ‘King of the Button Box’ is a double CD of tracks recorded by our most popular accordionist during his golden period of 1945 to 1956. There are 18 tracks on each CD all originally released by EMI’s prestigious Parlophone label. A splendid opportunity to enhance your collection of recorded performances by the legendary Jimmy Shand.
Jimmy Shand’s preferred instrument was a Hohner Morino developed by himself and Venancio Morino, the then chief accordion designer at the famous Hohner works in Germany - a box best known to all as ‘The Shand Morino’. (not the illustration shown)
Legal Note: ‘JIMMY SHAND’ is a registered trade mark used to brand a particular range of merchandise. This compilation of quality recordings made by the celebrated accordionist Jimmy Shand and originally released on EMI’s prestigious Parlophone label has no connection whatsoever with ‘JIMMY SHAND’ trade marked products.
"King of the Button Box: Jimmy Shand" ~ a problem of ‘quality’
It is curious that the people who amassed this particular collection keep repeating that these are quality recordings. There is a problem with that claim. Yes, the recordings are OK, as far as being Jimmy Shand and clean rather than scratchy and along the lines of old 78s… But, as far as the CDs and the processing that went on there ~
No! ~ this is not a quality production ~ cheaply printed, the inserts and on the CDs, which is OK, I could live with that, however, the CDs are your very cheap variety, the kind you purchase for your computer and burn off things on yourself. That is not the usual for commercially produced recordings. The commercial CDs tend to last longer, while those cheap CDs and the burner technology most of us have with our computers, is not so robust. This was a cheap burn, and that is unfortunate and in my books inexcusable. Maybe the bought a load of CD burners and stacked them to do a production run, but I really expect something more professional than a computer CD burn.
Yes, I’m glad for the listen, but if I had known that this was the way they’d produced this I probably wouldn’t have purchased it and would have chosen something else.
I have known this type of production, having done it on my own computer, to deteriorate in time and to even become unaccessible… So, you have been warned where I wasn’t…
Buyer beware…but it is a good listen if you are fond of Jimmy Shand’s music…
For those that might remember the days of tape, you might compare this as being the ‘ferric oxide’ to ‘chrome oxide’, the latter was the better quality…
Discussion: "How reliable are home-grown CD recordings?"
# Posted on May 21st 2007 by lazyhound