Comments from the CD Booklet
When Here Meets There is an exciting new collaboration between two young Canadian fiddlers at the top of their game. Shane Cook of Dorchester, Ontario is one of Canada’s most highly awarded old-time fiddlers: 3-time Canadian Open Fiddle champion, 3-time Canadian Grand Masters Fiddle Champion, Grand North American Fiddle Champion, and the only Canadian to win the US Grand National Fiddle Championship. Troy MacGillivray of Antigonish, Nova Scotia, is an accomplished fiddler, pianist and step dancer; he most recently won the 2008 East Coast Music Award for Instrumental Album of the Year. Individually, these two fiddlers are virtuosic musicians and dynamic performers; together, stimulating and feeding off of each other and their top-tier back-up musicians, they are inspirational.
The album provides an astonishing breadth of styles, tunes, and arrangements. While each fiddler has several opportunities to shine on solo sets that emphasize his particular strengths, my favourite sets on the album are those that Shane and Troy play together. There’s an obvious excitement and spark between the two players and their ensemble that is infectious. Their combined lift and rhythmic drive propel the music forward.
While each fiddler brings to the album a flavour of his own, the contrast between their playing is nothing but complementary. Perhaps my favourite tune on the album is “Archie Menzies”. After playing the tune through in unison, well-matched in style, tone, variations, and ornaments, and yet not erasing the unique sound of either, each fiddler plays the tune through by himself, each version excellent, and each version very different. There can be no mistake that Troy, gritty and strongly rhythmic, plays the tune through first and Shane, slightly smoother, with unique melodic variations, plays second. This is a wonderful opportunity to hear how two of the top players in their respective traditions shape the tune to make it their own. Shane has a considerable reputation amongst fiddlers for his individual, unique style that is not always predictable, but almost always recognizable for its daring, yet ever tasteful, melodic and rhythmic adventures. Troy demonstrates a similar inclination to flirt with stylistic boundaries, most notably in a number of original tunes included on the album. Some will challenge the listener; all will please.
Although the tunes are obviously very carefully arranged, they still manage to sound fresh and inspired, with a spark and energy that is easiest to capture before they have been endlessly rehearsed. Several of the transitions between tunes, in particular, are quite unusual and grab the listener’s attention. The play with textures, both between the two fiddlers and with the ensemble, is also especially effective. Techniques such as soloing, doubling of the melody by back-up musicians, harmonizing both whole tunes and short phrases here and there, and playing in different octaves all serve to highlight the talents of the individual musicians, as well as create an remarkable listening experience.
In short, this album provides something for everyone – for those who like the old standards and those who like the cutting edge. For those who are familiar with the playing of Shane Cook and Troy MacGillivray as individuals, their collaboration will surprise and delight. When Here Meets There, when Ontario meets Nova Scotia, when Canadian old-time, Cape Breton, French-Canadian, Shetland, Texas and other styles and tunes from a variety of traditions meet on this album, the result is truly magical.
Dr. Sherry Johnson
York University, Toronto
Oooooh!…I had planned on submitting this recording, but you beat me to it! This is officially my new favourite album…lots of different styles (ranging from Cape Breton to Texas Swing) and each number is both surprising and refreshing. The caliber of the entire album is such that I feel like clapping after every track 🙂 Troy and Shane are such wonderful, talented musicians and they give a great live performance, too. I was at one of their concerts during their Maritime CD release tour this fall and the energy and excitement beetween the musicians was so evident and infectious! My feet were still tapping days afterwards 🙂
Re: Track 15 - Gallagher’s Jig
Just a note…. even though the first tune in Track 15 is listed in the liner notes as Gallagher’s, it is not the same tune as what it is linked to in the thesession.org database… it’s actaully “The Castle” written by Sean Ryan (also known as “Sean Ryan’s Jig”). According to The Fiddler’s Companion website, it may have been mis-titled when Seán McGuire and Josephine Keegan published the tune in 1975 under the title “Gallagher’s Jig".
T:Sean Ryan’s Jig
S:McGuire & Keegan – Irish Tunes by the 100
AB | c2A BdB | AGE DB,G, | A,G,A, EGE | DEG AGE | c2A BdB |
AGE DB,G, | A,G,A, EGE | DB,G, A,2 :: AB | cBA aga | bag edB |
GBd g^fg | G,B,D GBd | cBc dcd | ede gab | age dBG | EFG A2 :|
(ABC’s taken from The Fiddler’s Companion, http://www.ibiblio.org/fiddlers/GAA_GAL.htm)
Oiy, another one…
The first tune in track 11 should be :
“Close to the Floor ”aka “Frog in the Well” aka “Father Tom’s Wager” (https://thesession.org/tunes/2956)
“Close to the Floor” aka “Walking the Floor” (https://thesession.org/tunes/1739)
I have updated the edits you have listed above…. I knew that some of them were labeled wrong, but I didn’t know what the correct tune names were, so thank you for that.
FYI…. lots of original tunes on the album… all superb!
New Tune Makers of 2007
Mary’s Return Home
Ottawa Valley Fiddle Camp 2007
Dr. Fiona Cuthil’s Hornpipe
Touring With Kristine
Dr. Kevin and Denise O’Halloran
The Suitcase Surprise
The Mischievous Combination
Being Jerry Holland
np, twin fiddler 🙂
On track 2 “A Winston Jig in A” is called “The Highland Jig” by one Sandy MacLean and the jig listed as “Traditional” is “Tipperty’s Jean” by Scott Skinner.