This is the Julie Fowlis setting from her Cuilidh album. Despite the family resemblance to Old Woman of the Milldust https://thesession.org/tunes/9365 which may be the original source, to my ear this is different enough to merit a separate listing. Thanks to kenny for help in pinning this down.
I agree, it’s different enough. I wonder if we can unlink all of the entries of "It is my lame leg I left behind" and "’Se Mo Chas Chrubach" from "Old wife."
I don’t agree. This particular version of Tripper’s is certainly very unlike the popular version, which is close to identical to parts of the Old Woman of the Milldust.
Yet still different
There’s no doubt these apples fell from the same tree but if each one has grown its own tradition and identity then where’s the wrong in calling them different tunes?
Re: The Tripper’s
Fab version here. 3rd tune in the set. https://youtu.be/NPHRODeXGlk