This Gloom On My Soul waltz

I know this as a Cape Breton slow air. Tune is from the Simon Fraser Collection which Paul Cranford publishes (cranfordpub.com). Beautiful recording of this by Ian MacDougall with Mac Morin accompanying on piano found on Glenn Graham’s Cape Breton FIddle Music, Making And Maintaining A Tradition. The CD accompanies the book of the same title. The book is a great resource for Cape Breton fiddlers.

I’ve added the ian MacDougall version that is on Failte: A Cape Breton Welcome. It is only a note down but I’m new to this site and wanted to try out adding settings.

I also heard Shelly Campbell play this at the Red Show Pub in Mabou when I was down a few weeks ago. She called it Heavy is My Fate although I heard “Heavy is My Feet!”

Mairearad Green and Mike Vass title it as Domnhuil and play it in Emaj in their recording A Day a Month. Beautiful rendition that rings around in my head.

The version known in the Gaelic world is from the Gaelic Group Cliar (arranged by them) featuring the dearly departed Maggie MacDonald, and the pen of Ian Lom http://www.celticlyricscorner.net/cliar/domhnallan.htm I don’t have access to his book… it’s probably this version that’s played by Mairearad Green and Mike Vass. It’s also played in G by Skipinnish on their album Skipinnish, it loses a lot in the dots without grace notes and fermatas… There are other version on youtube etc.
None of which are quite the same as the original, which can be found at 48 in The Capt Simon Fraser Collection, directly from NLS online. It leads itself to considerable ornamentation, Sara Jane Summers https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=qVAC5CF6gMk is probably one of the best versions..

play video

Would this be in D?

I know this lament as Heavy is my Fate, and this setting is based off of this version, in D: https://youtu.be/UCGpPwO-UP0

play video

This has quickly become one of my favorite airs to play, and I love playing it on the fiddle with generous use of double stops.