Transcribed from the playing of a fiddler in Sydney. She played the second to last bar lower pitches than I’ve seen transcribed from other sources, which most often go:
e|~a3g efed|cAGE FDD||
…or similar. I can only find 2 names for this on JC’s. One is "The Piper On Horseback" - a name also (mistakenly?) given to "The Fair-haired Lass", and the other is "Jig Away The Donkey". Both are slightly different settings from the one posted here.
Has anyone come across this tune, and what do people tend to call it?
Piper on horseback
This tune I have always associated with players from the North of Ireland. I have never heard it called by any other name than "The Piper On Horseback". It used to be played after "Jig Away The Donkey" (which is an entirely different tune) and followed by "The Three Scones Of Boxty/Baxty".
Cheers for the info Kenny. By the way: I transcribed this from a minidisc of this fiddler’s playing. She followed this reel with "The Little Bag of Spuds" in G. I thought it was a really nice change of key.
Same Tune, Same Title
I first learned this tune with this title from flute-player (Reverend) Gary Hastings around 1979 and it was a long time before I heard anybody except us wee northerners playing it. I have forgotten where Gary got it but it was most likely Cathal McConnell or the late Eddie Duffy (flute) or the late Mick Hoy (fiddle), all Fermanagh men. The reels "Jig Away the Donkey" and "The Three Scones of Boxty" are also tunes I associate with Mick and Eddie.
I had a feeling that "Jig Away The Donkey" was another title for "Jigging The Donkey"; it looks like someone transcribing this for the net got confused somewhere along the line. At least that title directs you to another setting of this tune on JC’s index tho’.
If anyone can be bothered to post different settings of this tune (e.g. the version you play Long Note), it would be very much appreciated. It’s not often I hear it played at sessions…
More or Less the Same
Both "Piper on H" and "Jig Away the D" (also learned from Gary) posted here are the same as I play them, give or take a few notes here and there. I rarely hear these tunes except at sessions in the north.
Aka. O’Connell’s Reel
You can find this tune as "O’Connell’s Reel" on page 97 of Hidden Fermanagh Book. And of course, it’s recorded by Laurence Nugent on "Hidden Fermanagh Vol.1." According to the notes, Eddie Duffy learned it from another Fermanagh flute player William Carroll.
This is *not* Jig Away the Donkey.
If you read all the comments above carefully, you’ll find nobody calls this reel "Jig Away the Donkey." I wonder who was the idiot who added the wrong alternative title.
Eileen Ivers, I believe - not an idiot, just a genuine mistake. Happens all the time.
Actually, the idiot was me - I added it as an alternative title. As for reason, see Kenny’s post.
I wasn’t referring to here on this site. Eileen Ivers recorded "Jig Away The Donkey" and called it "The Piper On Horseback", and I doubt very much whether it was generally called that before she made that recording, but everyone seems to have learned it from her CD, or second-hand from someone who did, and the wrong name has stuck. Thanks for removing it, Dow - maybe we can reverse history !
What did I remove? Oh god I’m confused :-)
Sorry Dow - it’s still there. I was sure it had gone. Ignore me. If you want to, as the person who posted the tune, you can remove "JATD" from the alternative titles list on the details page.
You’re talking about tune #1231, right? And saying that I should remove its alternative title of Piper On Horseback?
And Slainte is talking about this tune, #1247, saying I should remove its alternative title of Jig Away The Donkey.
The issue being that:
#1231 was recorded by Eileen Ivers under the incorrect title, and:
#1247 was recorded by some other musicians* under the incorrect title, probably also because of confusion arising from Eileen Ivers’ recording ("well if that other one was the POHB, then this one must be JATD").
Or am I just totally confused?
* Not sure about this, but off the top of my head, Cherish The Ladies and Far From Home???
So, we all agree that "The Piper on the Horseback" is the title for this tune, #1247, and probably not the original title for the tune #1231.
I just wanted to make it clear that neither Kenny nor LongNote suggest that "Jig Away the Donkey" is the title for this tune, #1247. And Hidden Fermanagh Book doesn’t list this tune #1247 as "Jig Away the Donkey," either.
Jig Away the Donkey, or not?
A bit of research shows "Far from Home" recorded this as "Jig Away the Donkey." See: http://www.irishtune.info/tune/934
Sorry Dow for calling you an idiot!
I’ll never let you forget it, Slainte. Next time I’m in Tokyo, I’ll get my revenge ;-)
Check out Cherish The Ladies’ recording of the tune. You can hear a clip at Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/Irish-Musicians-America-Cherish-Ladies/dp/B000000E7I
I’m really sorry. Hope it’s not as insulting as calling the Australian troops Austrian.
“The Piper On Horseback”.
To hear tune played =
Not the same tune…
As interesting as this discussion is, the notation here is not that of whatever Trouble in the Kitchen call Piper on Horseback on their album - if they do call it that at all, I haven’t checked the sleeve :-/
Of course I know that this is due to database matching but just sayin’ in case anyone comes across it via Trouble in the Kitchen search.
No, that tune is here https://thesession.org/tunes/1231
Go here for what could be another version (?) https://thesession.org/tunes/4364
The Piper on the Horseback
THE MILLER. Line engraving after the illumination in the Ellesmere manuscript of the ‘Canterbury Tales’ by Geoffrey Chaucer (c1340-1400): http://granger.artistwebsites.com/featured/image.html?catalogid=0017741
Got this off Athena Tergis’ album 2nd tune first track.
After transcribing this I realise that there is a transcription under another name - Piper On horseback:
Anyway there are some differences in this setting though its obviously the same tune
Not only that, but there is an actual duplication of this one too https://thesession.org/tunes/4364
Apologies dr Dow, but I was just going on the album listing under the above mentioned entry. At least if someone goes looking for that tune off that track it will be listed /linked