This is one of those fun-to-play, let-your-hair-down tunes that everyone recognizes, in the same class as the Sailor’s Hornpipe, The Irish Washer Woman, and a few others I can’t recollect at the moment. We played it in a Bristol session last Sunday, and, as usual, finished the 3rd playing with the alternative B part below, which always goes down well with the pub audience. Note the F nat in the 5th bar and the E flat in the 6th bar.
"alternative B part"
|:(3ddd d2 (3ddd d2|efgf edcB|cded cBAG|FGAG FDEF|
(3GGG G2 (3=FFF F2|(3EEE E2 (3_EEE E2|DGBe dcBA|1 G2B2 G2Bc :|2 G2B2 G4||
Trumpet hornpipe !
I would have to say that this is not a tune I have ever heard any Irish musician play, and one I’ve always personally loathed.
If it’s indicative of the type of tune played at sessions in Bristol, then sorry, but I wouldn’t be sitting in. I predict a discussion along the lines of "The Irish Waterman" will follow, but maybe not.
At the end of the day, if it’s a tune you like, then fine, but I never thought it would turn up on this website.
Roger the cabin boy
I wouldn’t say it’s played all that frequently, just very occasionally for a bit of fun, that’s all - as I indicated. Most of the musicians I know, in more than one musical genre, like to let their hair down sometimes. I can also assure you that The Trumpet isn’t an indicator of the general run of tunes played in my area. I also believe the tune has been around for a long time - it’s in O’Neill and elsewhere.
Kenny, no way does this even come close to "The Irish Waterman". That’s a true classic!
Perhaps the tune should be renamed "The Strumpet" - vulgar but good fun!
bigdave youre right - it is captain Pugwash…wow that brings me back to when I was 4- I cant see how this is either particularly fun to play or listen too.
Glad to hear that , Trevor. Maybe I will drop in on Bristol someday, after all!. And Dow, it is much,much worse than "The Irish Waterman" !!
When and where you play it depends on who’s listening. Last Sunday the country pub just outside Bristol had a couple of dozen lively 20-somethings who really appreciated it and the more regular ITM we played. Another pub, another clientele - no, I don’t think we would have played it.
The heck is this?
Looks like a series of arpeggios for the G major and D major chords.
I’ve never been bewrayethed in my life. And I don’t believe even Frankie Gavin could make anything of this particular tune.
An archaic form of "betray". Sort of what this tune does to good musical taste. 🙂
Arpeggios in The Trumpet
Every tune I’ve come across consists of fragments of scales and arpeggios - it’s characteristic of western music, so I don’t see a problem with the arpeggios in this tune - 3 ascending G maj, 1 descending ditto, 1 D7, and a few fragments. And plenty of scale passages, including a complete descending scale. Any page of O’Neill will give plenty of similar examples. Anyway, it’s all good practice for Welsh harp hornpipes 🙂
e flat,my arse,pooka! - any supernatural entity can easily tell that the home key is D sharp major…
still hung up on the even numbers???
that flan o’brien’s a bit of a bugger,is n’t he!
ps: give my regards to jimmy stewart & harvey
Trumpet Hornpipe - its Northumbrian
The Trumpet Hornpipe doesn’t work if you play it as an Irish Hornpipe. It doesn’t really work if you play it in the English style asits too stodgey. You need toplay it in the Northumbrian (more specifically the Tyneside) style with very articulated notes, quite a bit of swing and lots of bounce. Good Northumbrian players make this one fly.
Angels of the North
The Trumpet is played a lot in Northumberland but is it Northumbrian? Specifically what source??
It’s in O’Niell’s - therefore must have had an Irish identity at some point in it’s history - and I’ve got a ceili band recording of it. It probably wouldn’t sound so bad if it hadn’t been murdered by Capt. Pugwash. It’s sounds a nice wee fun tune on the box, in between all the big reel sets - light relief.
Awaking the BOFs ~
T: Strumpet, The
|: (3DEF |
(3GGG G2 (3GGG G2 | B>GB>d g>dB>G | (3DDD D2 (3DDD D2 | F*DF>A d>B (3cBA |
(3GGG G2 (3GGG G2 |B>GB*d g2 a>g|f>ag>f e>gf>e| (3ddd d>^c d2 :|
|: B>=c |
(3ddd d2 (3ddd d2 | e*fg>f e>dc*B | c>de>d c>BA*G | F>GA>G F*DE>F |
(3GGG G2 (3=FFF F2|(3EEE E2 (3^DDD D2 |(3DED fe (3ded (3cBA | G2 B2 G2 :|
Contributing to the delinquency of minors…
the tune is scottish
Is that so ?
Evidence for that , please ?
The Trumpet Hornpipe
Listen to Sean McGuire play this tune: http://www.rte.ie/radio1/thelatesession/rams/27march.smil (starts around 10:30)
The whole programme "A Tribute to Sean McGuire" was originally broadcast on 27th March in 2005, and found in the Late Session Programme Listing 2005: http://www.rte.ie/radio1/story/1034196.html
Love it or loathe it
If you play any kind of box then you just have to be able to play it. It is the equivalent of having a guitar, and not learning the opening bars to stairway to heaven. It is far less hassle to crank it out on demand and get on with things, than to try to explain to some drunk who only knows the name of one tune for the instrument why not.
You have to learn the sailors hornpipe too!
I think its funny the amount of ITM snobs on here now. Whatever tune someone wants to play should be up to them. If a children’s programme used this hornpipe as it’s theme tune, surely it should be welcomed as an introduction to Trad music, lets face it there are not as many kids in sessions as there are at the local clubs.
The tune is a bit of fun and entertaining, if you think otherwise, maybe you should ask yourself why you play the music in the first place.
The ‘fun’ is also in making comment Accordionstu, don’t read everything you find here as ‘serious’. We all like to have a laugh now and then. The truth is usually cruel in that sometimes name calling, or passing judgement on others, is signs of our suffering the affliction ourselves. Don’t let the banter overcome your senses. I have in the past, and it doesn’t accomplish much of use…
Our rants and banter are mostly "a bit of fun and entertaining", for us anyway… It may be wise for others who haven’t that understanding or appreciation to just let it pass overhead, or underfoot, wherever you find yourself, real or imagined…
Keep the faith ~ ‘c’ 😉
You got there before me "c". I’ll let this one pass.
Cheers Ceolachan for the comment, I enjoy reading the comments on here as much as anyone, however I thought that the first comment and use of the word ‘loathed’ . was stronger than banter. But I made my comment and would hope that neither you or Kenny take it too serious.
It’s only a comment and only a laugh after all.
Fair play stu ~ ‘loathed’ is actually a nice word in a fun sort of way, including how it forms in the mouth and reverberates in the ears. We all at some point slip up and let our negative feelings escape toward something we might consider ‘dag’ (do a search with ‘dag’ in ‘discussions’) or that we’ve overplayed or heard too many times being ripped through. But, it isn’t one I find myself using, though the sentiment may be felt, especially with the increasing wave of ‘new’ tunes and so-called ‘new’ ways of treating them…myself not excepted… 😉
I see where you are coming from Ceolachan, I suppose murder is a nice word, especially in a Scottish accent. I must admit I enjoy the trumpet hornpipe owing to my previous life in a marching band but the tune that drives me mad now is the masons apron. Apart from hearing it murdered at every session, I was eventually put off by watching Davy Arthur at our local on banjo, it was a blur and a messy blur at that.
Lets see some more sliabh lucra tunes.
“I would have to say that this is not a tune I have ever heard any Irish musician play”
Barney McKenna and that lad who plays the mandolin with the dubliners did this one in between Cheif O’neills and the mullingar races on their 40 years tour. I think it write off a tune like this just because it’s light hearted and in a cartoon is dumb,
Some years ago the band ‘Dingle Spike’ used to play a great version of this. The secret seemed be in ‘crunching’ the triplets. Only problen was u had to get your bow rehaired….
Is that pub still there? Can’t even remember the name of it……
Yeah hoopoe, the triplets are the key. On my whistle I play them crisp and percussive with lots of tongue, then put a bit of swagger and swing into the bit that comes directly after for contrast. If you play this tune straight off the dots it is an absolute dog, you need to put some character in it, then it comes right to life.
This tune appears in the Ironbridge Hornpipe, a set of tunes taken from one of three manuscripts of John Moore, held in the Vaughan Williams library. The editor believes the tunes were written down between 1837 and 1840.
Is that this John Moore, who collected music on the Isle of Man? http://www.mustrad.org.uk/reviews/j_moore.htm
I looked up the EFDSS’s "Take 6" online browser thingamajig: http://library.efdss.org/archives/index.html You can view various bits of manuscript there - dunno if your tune is visible, but a solid page of results show when searching for ‘hornpipe.’ Might save those jpgs and print ‘em out, as I did years ago with FARNE and things like the Vickers Manuscript.
I know a few people have pointed to this tune being in O’Neill’s, and in a couple of other collections…
It’s interesting. Local lore has it that the tune was written by one Tommy Edmondson, who died in 2001… but according to the eulogy here: http://www.northumbrian.info/musicians/edmondson.htm it was only collected from his playing back in the fifties. Now… if the tune appears elsewhere, then he can’t have written it, but the story goes that it was his, and that he was never paid other than a fee for agreeing to record it in the first place. Who knows. The tune, though, is definitely a Northumbrian staple.
And yes, it’s bloody awful.
The Tommy Edmondson eulogy
Must point out that the eulogy doesn’t credit Tommy with writing the tune. Just playing it.
I’ve seen this tune credited to Purcell. Alistair Hardy, in his wonderful book the Caledonian Companion, prints it in e-flat and says that it comes from Köhlers’ Violin Repository, which dates to the 1880s. Is there a danger of snobbery here? Why must a tune be scorned because it is popular and well known?
The Captain Pugwash character was created by a one John Ryan:
As his name was "John Ryan", it’s not surprising that he was partial to daggy tunes! 😉
Re: The Trumpet
Apparently Tom Edmundson learned this one from Jimmy Shand. Where it came from before that is anyone’s guess, but I imagine its either a Scottish or Northumbrian tune..
Re: The Trumpet
Because of the rather rancorous comments battle here I looked up the TV series on YT and rather enjoyed it. It is wacky and fun. Because of it, and the controversy in the comments, I very much want to learn the tune.
The Trumpet, X:5
I like this hoary old pot boiler. But anytime I’ve heard it, those triplets, (3GGG etc., have always been played as G/2G/2G G2. Though, writing that as a triplet may be a matter of notation convention.
I also like the last time ending; I’ve forgotten where I came across it. It’s definitely not Irish (or even folkish) but it does add a flourish.
Re: The Trumpet
I’m not sure how those "2’s" got into the ABC code. It should read:
But anytime I’ve heard it, those triplets, (3GGG etc., have always been played as G/G/G
Re: The Trumpet
And just because a tune appears in ONeills doesn’t mean it’s originally Irish!