Piper In The Meadow Straying - set dance
Source. Finbar and Eddie Furey
Transcription: Gian Marco P.
This tune is not a hornpipe. I’s a SET DANCE.
Not only is it a set dance, it’s also near as damn it ‘Deck the Halls with Boughs of Holly’.
Play "Deck the Halls etc" at other than a Christmas session and I think eyebrows would raised, but this one, the resemblance probably wouldn’t be noticed all that much out of context.
hey, this was my set dance. Like i mean it was the tune i chose for my set dance. I can’t actually remember the dance i did to it though…hmmmmm….good tune but.
Er….a set dance can be a hornpipe. It can be both. Unless of course it’s a double jig, not a hornpipe. It can’t be both of those. *grin* But just because a hornpipe is a set dance doesn’t mean it’s not a hornpipe…
anyway this tune doesn’t seem to me a hornpipe, and it’s not played swung as a hornpipe.
Well, it’s on the list of An Coimisiun’s set dances as a hornpipe (which is how Fraser could dance his/her non-traditional set to it) — I’ve never heard the Furey setting, but keep in mind that there are two ways to play hornpipes — the swung way (dah dee dah dee dah dee dah) and the straight way (dit dit dit dit dit dit dit dit), and both are considered correct (or rather, both are not considered correct, depending upon whether you’re a glass-full or glass-empty kind of person).
I shall leave the argument as to which way is correct up to the ethnomusicologists — insofar as I know, the swung way originated in England and spread it’s way into Ireland through Dublin in the mid-to-late 1700’s and is now the most common (but not necessarily only) way to play hornpipes.
Even accepting Zina’s points, it seems misleading to have this tune classified under hornpipes. I think few people looking for it would expect to find it in under this classification.
The structure of the tune is worth a comment. As given here, it is in the form AABABA (with A being 8 bars and B only 4). Note that A is actually a 4 bar phrase repeated, with only the last beat changing (B2 becomes G2).
This structure is not that of the usual hornpipe - "AABB" or "AABBCC" with A and B (and C) being 8 bars. Since this is a dance tune and the dance community classifies this as a set dance, it should probably be listed here as a set dance.
That being said, set dances that are not in triplet rhythm are played with a hornpipe rhythm, which (if we insist on transcribing them in 4/4 or 2/2) has TWO beats per measure, with essentially equal emphasis on each. To adopt Zina’s phrasing above, this would better be phrased (DAH dee dee dee DAH dee dee dee) or even better (DEE dah dah dah DEE dah dah dah).
Any "swing" feel of the hornpipe comes from the emphasis on each of the two beats.
Note that reels and double jigs also have 2 beats to the measure (despite the fact that they are traditionally transcribed in 4/4 or 6/8). In reels and double jigs, however, there is a light emphasis on beat 2 of the measure.
A tin whistle version here
piper inthe meadow
there was a version of this tune on a Horslips album back in the 70s if anyone can find it - no idea what happened to my copy. I think the album was called ‘Drive the Cold Winter Away’