Dark Girl Dressed In Blue (polka) on The Session

Dark Girl Dressed in Blue.

I’ve always understood this to be Southern English.Does anyone have any more explicit details about it?
Noel Jackson
Angels of the North

Dark Girl Dressed in Blue

Noel, you might be thinking of the polka popularised by Rod Stradling and the Old Swan Band on their “No Reels” LP FRR011. Although that one is also played in D (to suit G/D melodeon players) it’s quite different to the one posted here, having a C natural in the second strain and ending on an unresolved chord which makes a nice excuse for starting again from the top. Although it’s Irish in origin, having been learned from a 1960s ? recording of Donegal fiddler John Doherty, nowadays it’s usually regarded as an English tune and is consequently played in a rather heavy-footed style.
Colin Turner

I’m sure I’ve heard this tune played by Sliabh Luachra musicians. They seem to be insatiable polkophiles - they’ll take polkas from the four corners of the Earth (if four cornered it be) and make them their own.

This particular one reminds me of a certain Scots or Northumbrian tune, the name of which forget. But it responds well to the itchy-footed Kerry treatment.

David, I reckon you’re thinking of the 1st part of “Because He Was A Bonnie Lad” in G out of the Northumbrian minstrelsy, which goes something like: c|B>A Gg|e/f/g d>B|cedB cAA… I thought the same thing when I first saw this post but the 2nd part’s a lot different.

Call me a bomber-jacket, but I maintain the stance this tune is a descendant of the said Northumbrian tune, or that the two have a common ancestor. I suspect that somebody heard the original tune and remembered the first part but forgot the 2nd part and made up another bit in its place… or perhaps they just didn’t like the 2nd part and thought they could do better.

Dark and Moody it ain’t - D Major

Nicely done Ceolachan--finally, a setting that makes sense under the fingers.

“The Girl With the Blue Dress On” ~ good friends

Submitted on May 12th 2006 by OsvaldoLaviosa.
https://thesession.org/tunes/5762

Dark Girl Dresed In Blue (in D maj)

You can see (as well as hear) this polka being played on
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YIrzeY9iwo. It’s the second tune, and is played in D major.

play video

The tunes played in the video are Farewell To Whiskey, The Dark Girl Dressed In Blue, and The Killavil Postman (a barndance).
The musicians (L-R) are Johnny Óg, Steve Simonds, Tomás Neachtain, Charlie Lennon and daughter Eilish, and Liam O’Hara.
There’s a second guitar player whose face can’t be seen, but he’s believed to be the Dubliner Dave Flynn.
(Many thanks to various contributers to the comments on Discussion #14004 and Tune #7137 for the above information)

I recently learned this one from Siobhan Ni Cholarain following on after My Love is but a Lassie (i.e. ‘Farewell to Whiskey’ as listed above)

“Dark Girl” ~ Bulmer & Sharpley

ABCing a dotted eighth ~ 3/ ~

Another way to make it a dotted note through ABCs ~

From ~ | FD D-D/ :| ~ to ~ | FD D3/ :|

“The Dark Girl Dressed in Blue”

This is not the tune by this name played by Johnny Doherty…

The tune played by Johnny Doherty is this one https://thesession.org/tunes/11982 (posted by ‘c’) as is the one on the Old Swan Band recording referred to in the first two posts. Well, at least, to my ear, they are both relatives of ‘Over the Waterfall’.