After recommending this to Caroline as a minor key reel good for sessions, I realized it wasn’t in the tune section on this site yet. So here it is, in a fairly simple setting. You can put triplets on most of the quarter notes throughout the tune to spice it up a little. See O’Neill’s for the same minor setting with too much ornamentation.
I’ve also heard this tune played with c sharps throughout, with no other changes, to place it squarely in D major—like learning two tunes in one. This is how it’s shown in Breathnach’s volume 1, and The Northern Fiddler hasit transcribed from Johnny Doherty in a decidedly Donegal setting, also in D major.
The same name
sorry for my english. Iknow to play a slip jig whit the same name, but the tune is totally different. I submitted this tune here but is a slip jig.
just listening to some tape of seamus ennis and i realised that after some spiel about a little girl and a leprechaun or an odd little man he plays this tune once through on whistle calling it the smokey house and warning people not to play it in presence of the aforementioned little girl or she’ll run a mile
anyone else call it the smokey house i wonder
That little story can also be found in Carson’s "Last Night’s Fun". Stories are fun. When I get the book back I can post the whole thing. Unless you (ed) want to write it down from the tape. :-)
This is the tune on Altans’ CD Blackwater, instead of the one that you’d hop too through the recordings bit.
Eeeeee, that story was confusing, I just listened to it! But that’s cool! I love stories wheeeee!!!
I prefer this in Amix.
Quite nice! Nice on the whistle, probabley on the fiddle too! Cool! From NiamhB
I agree that the O’Niell’s version is too heavy on ornamentation. Maybe grace notes and what not are easier to play on the fiddle, which the book was written for, than on the mandolin, especially when, like me, you don’t really know how to play. Great tune, thanks for this version.
Played by Altan, starting about 4.10
"I prefer this in Amix." -Me too!
A great tune, to be piped hot in the usual mixolydian mode!
Vallely Brothers & Tiarnan O Duinnchinn
Second tune http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRXe_HFvQ0g
Many melodies titles and versions?
The number of tunes, titles and settings in the question intrigued me, so
I tried both text search (the blackhaired lass) and music search (with the five settings) in the Melodycatcher
Results surprised me. But I lack the knowledge to judge how relevant they are:
The text search resulted in 13 results
For music search I used enough notes to get only similar results per search;
Setting1 and 3 showed 3 similar melodies (there is at least one note different between setttin 1 and 3 after the notes I used for this search)
Setting 2 delivered two similar melodies, setting 4 also two and section 5 one melody all similar per search but quite different.between all searches
For me it seems complex to judge about different melodies and versions while I did not even use other titles for text search… But it might be interesting for someone with more knowledge to repeat this type of search to see if further details are of help..
Another title too
In addition to including this tune as The Black Haired Lass (reel #73) in her tunebook A Drop in the Ocean, Josephine Keegan also prints a very similar setting under the title The Kilcogy Reel (reel #55). The more names the merrier, eh?
The Blackhaired Lass, X:6
The first version here in A dorian is my favorite. But of versions in A mixolydian this one mostly from Tradschool.com is the setting I prefer.